After the groundbreaking decision1 from the Constitutional Council of France, last month against the three strikes law adopted in May, the. Demonstrations and protests against the Haute Autorité pour la diffusion des œuvres et la protection des droits sur internet (HADOPI) law. 1 reference. But the correct inferences to draw are that HADOPI and Ley Sinde are just an expensive waste of time, and that people don’t expect to get.
|Published (Last):||3 March 2015|
|PDF File Size:||12.78 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||6.82 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Spain is considered by many to be the worst offender in Western Europe when it comes to internet copyright infrigments. Haropi the bill can become law, the National Assembly and Senate must combine their passed bills, according to sources] French legislators today approved, by a vote toa pioneering bill in French allowing authorities to cut off internet access and impose fines on those found to have downloaded copyrighted material without authorisation.
As a chain of minor changes in the currently accepted laws, the new rule can be implemented without attracting public attention.
Cities, cultural policy and governance. In addition, it shows that there is a market for the content, but it is economically leu for consumers to take part. Cookies enable us to collect information that helps us personalise your experience and improve the functionality and performance of our site.
From global to local in intellectual property 2. Why is Belgium ahead of the last 2? At the time of writing, these measures will not start until Goodwins, Production is getting cheaper in a lot of ways, but it’ll always take a lot of people to put together stuff like GOT or Breaking Bad or whatever. Have a Techdirt Account?
But go look at the credits for, say, Game of Thrones. Yet, IP addresses cannot constitute a valid proof:. In addition there were concerns expressed by the leg societies, the press and major Web sites.
Inthe Report states: Anonymous Coward19 Feb 3: From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. That ads up to a shit ton of money. Ley Sinde would key taken perhaps the same path as the French law, had it not been revealed that there was at least another actor intervening in the process.
The Bill was presented as the first visible measure of the Spanish government to fight a financial crisis. If, in the 6 months following the first step, a repeat offense is suspected by the copyright holder, his representative, the ISP or HADOPI, the second step of the procedure is invoked.
Section two will start a judiciary procedure in the courts of administrative appeals if content is not voluntarily withdrawn; the court will dictate authorisation or denial of measures imposed by section two Article A whole lot gets raked off in big money deals for marquee actors, directors, singers, whatever.
The French government created a promotional website in support of the country’s entertainment industry. PDF, accessed 7 May I am very surprised French courts normally include a college of three judges.
HADOPI raises from the dead, still as flawed
The judge could also decide a one-month internet suspension as complementary penalty. The leey has been challenged on several grounds:. However, in its decision on HADOPI 1 the Constitutional Council also contended that such presumption of guilt could only be acceptable if the penalty was not higher than a fine, and on the condition that: Learn how your comment data is processed.
And don’t forget all the cash scumbags like Ari Emmanuel suck off. Skip to main content.
HADOPI May Be Succeeding — In Driving French Customers To Dotcom’s Mega | Techdirt
However, in its decision on HADOPI 1 the Constitutional Council also contended that such presumption of guilt could only be acceptable if the penalty was not higher than a fine, and on the condition that:. The law received votes in favor with 19 against and one abstention.
Ley Sinde as a case of policy laundering Policy laundering is a concept emanating largely in information policy activism. Anonymous Coward19 Feb 1: CuriosityStream 2 Year Subscription 0.
HADOPI May Be Succeeding — In Driving French Customers To Dotcom’s Mega
This was the last step required before the regulations detailed in the law could be developed and the commission to review infringement claims established. The law passed without political alliances, discussion or negotiation in December and came into leyy in March Netflix produced House Of Cards for similar money without any problems, for example.
The law passed, but the authorisations of blocking Internet access through ISPs activity given by the European Directive is, in practice, still unresolved.
Once all parties are informed user and Internet service provider about the reasons and possible resolution measures, they have 48 hours to voluntarily take down unlawful content.
Fraudulent uses of IP addresses are widespread and no security software can protect an internet access from being hacked; Researchers from the University of Washington have shown that identifying copyrights infringers based on IP addresses collected through peer-to-peer websites monitoring was an extremely precarious method 9. Your IP address is The leading French consumer association UFC Que Choisir has positioned itself against the law and has set up a website to support opposition.
No private person is getting prosecuted. In November the Spanish government proposed a new copy protection law, the Sustainable Economy Bill, in order to address many copyright infringement issues across the leey.
Big win for the industry any way you look at it.
HADOPI raises from the dead, still as flawed – La Quadrature du Net
There have been considerable differences in the process of implementation of the Directives. It’s just a matter of the recording and film industries offering the public what they want, in a form they want, at a reasonable price. The key word in all this is reasonable pricing. But the correct inferences to draw are that HADOPI and Ley Sinde are just an expensive waste of time, and that people don’t expect to get everything for free, as the popularity in France and Spain of Dotcom’s paid-for Mega service shows.
Finally, the issue of temporal pressure: FACUA gathered more than 40, signatures from their campaign. Interviewed by Bob Garfield.
The only real differences are in politicians being far more clear about their intentions in Netherlands.